Mill Creek

Bayville, NY · American

Neighborhood go-to with a full bar & warm dining room serving seafood, steaks & other American eats.

disco cater
24hr lead time · Delivery & Pickup
← Back to Catering Map
Mill Creek

Mill Creek

📍 275 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
American

APPETIZERS

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Crispy Calamari “Tuscan Style”

hot cherry peppers, marinara, garlic aioli

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chili Pop Shrimp

baby shrimp, sweet chili sauce

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Three Cheese Spinach & Artichoke Fondue

tri-color tortilla chips

$40.00+|Serves 6-7+
Classic Chicken Wings

hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery

$65.00+|Serves 6-7+
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls

Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce

$65.00+|Serves 6-7+
Cheeseburger Sliders

cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, potato rolls

$65.00+|Serves 6-7+
Parmesan Artichoke Risotto Cakes

pomodoro

$50.00+|Serves 6-7+
Brie Stuffed Pretzel

brown sugar, fig jam

$50.00+|Serves 6-7+
Pigs in a Blanket

ketchup & mustard

$50.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Fingers

honey mustard

$50.00+|Serves 6-7+
Potato & Cheese Pierogies

bacon brown butter, chives, sour cream

$50.00+|Serves 6-7+
Baked Little Neck Clams Oreganata

roasted garlic, white wine, olive oil, parmesan bread crumbs

$60.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chilled Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

By the dozen

$30.00|Serves 2-4+

PASTA

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Rigatoni Seafood

jumbo shrimp, calamari, white wine, garlic & olive oil | fra diavolo or red or white

$90.00+|Serves 6-6+
“Classic” Linguine w/ Clam Sauce

whole littleneck & fresh chopped clams | red or white

$80.00+|Serves 6-6+
Zucchini Linguine

roasted tomato-garlic white wine broth with baby shrimp

$65.00+|Serves 6-6+
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak

grilled portobello mushrooms, gorgonzola, porcini mushroom-sage cream sauce

$90.00+|Serves 6-6+
Homemade Macaroni & Cheese

cheddar cheese, American cheese, fresh cream, baked-buttered bread crumbs

$65.00+|Serves 6-6+
Rigatoni & Chicken

spinach, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, basil, lemon-garlic olive oil

$75.00+|Serves 6-6+
Penne a la Vodka

crushed red pepper, tomatoes, cream

$65.00+|Serves 6-6+
Rigatoni Pomodoro

fresh mozzarella

$65.00+|Serves 6-6+
Puttanesca

filetto di pomodoro, roasted garlic, black olives, capers

$65.00+|Serves 6-6+
Bolognese

classic meat sauce

$75.00+|Serves 6-6+
Pink Carbonara

onions, smoked bacon, cream, pomodoro

$65.00+|Serves 6-6+
Eggplant Parmigiana
$75.00+|Serves 6-6+

CHICKEN

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Sautéed Chicken

diced Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, lemon scampi, olive oil, parmesan roasted potatoes

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Grilled Chicken Bruschetta

grape tomatoes, red onion, fresh mozzarella, basil, balsamic glaze

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Schnitzel

chicken cutlets, mushroom gravy

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Scarpariello

Italian sausage, hot cherry peppers, lemon, white wine, garlic, rosemary

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Grilled Chicken

honey mustard

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Blackened Chicken

honey mustard

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Francaise
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Marsala
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Piccata
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Chicken Parmigiana
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+

SEAFOOD

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Sole Oreganata

chopped tomatoes, spinach, roasted garlic-lemon olive oil

$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Jumbo Shrimp Francaise
$100.00+|Serves 6-7+
Jumbo Shrimp Piccata
$100.00+|Serves 6-7+
Jumbo Shrimp Oreganata
$100.00+|Serves 6-7+
Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana
$100.00+|Serves 6-7+
Mustard Grilled Salmon
$90.00+|Serves 6-7+
Grilled Salmon
$90.00+|Serves 6-7+
Blackened Salmon
$90.00+|Serves 6-7+
Filet of Sole Francaise
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Filet of Sole Almondine
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+
Filet of Sole Piccata
$85.00+|Serves 6-7+

MEAT

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Grilled Marinated Sliced Skirt Steak
$160.00|Serves 6-7+
Grilled Filet Mignon

3 oz. per person, au poivre

$160.00|Serves 6-7+
Classic Meatloaf

crispy onions, country gravy

$75.00|Serves 6-7+
Grandma’s Meatballs

basil pomodoro

$75.00|Serves 6-7+
Sauerbraten Short Ribs

orders must be placed 48 hours prior to pickup

$100.00|Serves 6-7+

SALADS

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Market Salad

field greens, garden vegetables, choice of dressing

$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Caesar Salad

shaved parmesan, rustic croutons

$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Baby Field Green Salad

dried cranberries, candied walnuts, maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette

$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Mediterranean Salad

cucumber, red onions, kalamata olives, feta, baby greens, grape tomatoes, garbanzo beans, Greek vinaigrette

$55.00+|Serves 6-7+

SIDES

HALF TRAY SERVES 6-7 | FULL TRAY SERVES 10-12

Parmesan Potatoes
$40.00+|Serves 6-7+
Mashed Potatoes
$40.00+|Serves 6-7+
Mixed Vegetables
$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Steamed Broccoli
$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Sautéed Broccoli
$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Steamed Spinach
$55.00+|Serves 6-7+
Sautéed Spinach
$55.00+|Serves 6-7+

DESSERTS

Junior’s Cheesecake
$90.00|Serves 8-10
Oreo Mousse Pie
$90.00|Serves 8-10
Order Summary
Mill Creek
Browse the menu and click
any item to get started